Jessie Weston: From Ritual to Romance (1920)
Jessie Laidlay Weston's From Ritual to Romance revolutionized Grail studies by arguing the legend derives from ancient fertility cults and nature worship, not purely Christian origins. Though later scholars questioned her methods, her influence remains profound—T.S. Eliot's "The Waste Land" (1922) draws directly from Weston's thesis.
On the Maiden figure: Weston identified the Grail Maiden and Well Maidens as fertility goddesses linked to vegetation cults and Mystery religions (Tammuz, Adonis, Attis). The maidens serve functions similar to priestesses in ancient Mystery cults. Their violation or absence causes the Wasteland; their return restores fertility.
Weston's framework:
- Grail Procession parallels ancient Mystery cult rituals
- Cup, Lance, Sword, Stone = symbols of ancient fertility religions
- Fisher King = vegetation deity whose health affects the land
- Maidens = personifications of Earth's fertility
Chapter on "The Freeing of the Waters" argues maiden figures represent water sources (wells, springs) essential for fertility—their despoiling creates ecological and spiritual devastation. The quest becomes restoration of right relationship with feminine/water/fertility powers.
Influence and controversy: Murray Ewing notes Weston "sees surviving Grail romances as written by people ignorant of their deeper meaning"—she believed medieval authors preserved ancient pagan material without understanding its original significance. This methodological assumption—that conscious Christian authors unconsciously transmitted pagan religion—has been critiqued as over-reliance on James Frazer's Golden Bough and speculative comparative method.